bioRxiv2025
BackgroundChimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T-cell therapies are highly efficacious for several different hematologic cancers. However, for most CAR T targets it is observed that low surface antigen density on tumors can significantly reduce therapeutic efficacy. Here, we explore this dynamic in the context of CD72, a surface antigen we recently found as a promising target for refractory B-cell cancers, but for which CD72 low antigen density can lead to therapeutic resistance in preclinical models. MethodsPrimary samples were accessed via institutional review board-approved protocols. Affinity-matured and humanized nanobody clones were previously described in Temple et al.1 CAR T-cells were generated via lentiviral transduction. In vitro cytotoxicity assays were performed using luciferase-labeled cell lines. In vivo studies were performed using cell line- or patient-derived xenografts implanted in NOD scid gamma (NSG) mice. ResultsWe first confirmed ubiquitous CD72 expression across a range of primary B-cell non-Hodgkin lymphomas. We further found that after resistance to CD19-directed therapies, across both B-cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia (B-ALL) models and primary tumor samples, surface CD72 expression was largely preserved while CD22 expression was significantly diminished. Affinity maturation of a nanobody targeting CD72, when incorporated into chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T-cells, led to more effective elimination in vitro of isogenic models of CD72 low-expressing tumors. These results suggested that nanobody-based CAR T-cells (nanoCARs) may exhibit a similar relationship between binder affinity, antigen expression, and efficacy as previously demonstrated only for scFv-based CAR T-cells. Surprisingly, however, this significantly improved in vitro efficacy only translated to modest in vivo survival benefit. As a parallel strategy to enhance CAR T function, we found that the small molecule bryostatin could also significantly increase CD72 surface antigen density on B-cell malignancy models. Structural modeling and biochemical analysis identified critical residues improving CD72 antigen recognition of our lead affinity-matured nanobody. ConclusionsTogether, these findings support affinity-matured CD72 nanoCARs as a potential immunotherapy product for CD19-refractory B-cell cancers. Our results also suggest that for B-ALL in particular, CD72 may be a preferable second-line immunotherapy target over CD22. What is already known on this topicPrevious work using single chain variable fragment (scFv) based CAR Ts has suggested that improving affinity for target antigen could potentially help mitigate tumor resistance mediated by antigen downregulation, or baseline low antigen density. However, it is unknown whether this same dynamic holds for CAR T-cells that utilize different antigen recognition elements, such as nanobodies. What this study addsHere we show that affinity maturation of nanobody-based CAR T-cells (nanoCARs) targeting CD72 can improve their in vitro efficacy versus CD72-low tumors; however, in vivo efficacy differences are more modest. Furthermore, we show that for refractory B-cell malignancies, surface CD72 appears preserved after CD19 resistance even in situations where CD22 is strongly downregulated. How this study might affect research, practice or policyCD72 warrants further investigation as a preferred immunotherapy target in the context of CD19-refractory B-cell cancers, though nanobody affinity maturation is not a universal solution to the challenge of low tumor surface antigen density.