Comparative Phylogenomics and Phylotranscriptomics Provide Insights into the Genetic Complexity of Nitrogen Fixing Root Nodule Symbiosis
Plant root nodule symbiosis (RNS) with mutualistic nitrogen-fixing bacteria is restricted to a single clade of angiosperms, the Nitrogen-Fixing Nodulation Clade (NFNC), and is best understood in the legume family. It is widely accepted that nodulation originated through the assembly of modules recruited from existing functions, such as mycorrhizal symbiosis, polar growth, and lateral root development. Because nodulating species are scattered within the NFNC, the number of times nodulation has evolved or has been lost has been a matter of considerable speculation. This interesting evolutionary question has practical implications concerning the ease with which nodulation might be engineered in non-nodulating crop plants. Nodulating species share many commonalities, due either to divergence from a common ancestor over 100 million years ago or to convergence or deep homology following independent origins over that same time period. In either case, comparative analyses of diverse nodulation syndromes can provide insights into constraints on nodulation--what must be acquired or cannot be lost for a functional symbiosis--and what the latitude is for variation in the symbiosis. However, much remains to be learned about nodulation, especially outside of legumes. Here we present new information across the spectrum of nodulating groups. We find no evidence for convergence at the level of amino acid residues or gene family expansion across the NFNC. Our phylogenomic analyses further emphasize the uniqueness of the transcription factor, NIN, as a master regulator of nodulation, and identify key mutations affecting its function across the NFNC. We find that nodulation genes are over-represented among orthologous gene groups (OGs) present in the NFNC common ancestor, but that lineage-specific OGs play major roles in nodulation. We identified over 900,000 conserved noncoding elements (CNEs), of which over 300,000 were unique to NFNC species. A significant proportion of these are associated with nodulation-related genes and thus are candidates for transcriptional regulators.