bioRxiv Science⌕ Search

Biology subjects

Myers, M. A.

Publications and source records attributed to Myers, M. A..

9 recordsLinked to original sources

Statistical Inconsistency of Error-correction Objectives for Perfect Phylogenies

The binary perfect phylogeny, in which each mutation arises exactly once on an evolutionary tree and is never lost, is a well-studied idealized phylogenetic model. When observed data has errors, a common approach to phylogeny inference is to seek a tree that minimizes the number of error corrections ("flips") needed to fit a perfect phylogeny. These objectives draw on an intuitive justification: minimizing implied errors should prefer the true tree in expectation. We test this assumption using a generative model with independent errors and prove that error-correction objectives are statistically inconsistent for all positive error rates: in expectation, the minimum-cost tree need not be the true tree. Our proof is constructive and yields counterexamples involving any tree topology and any positive error rates, demonstrating the ubiquity of the phenomenon. The core problem is that tree topologies can explain observed mutation patterns with fewer errors than actually occurred, and differ in their ability to do so, introducing systematic bias. This mechanism is distinct from previously identified sources of inconsistency such as homoplasy or incomplete lineage sorting, since the error-free setting is trivially consistent for perfect phylogenies. We investigate how often this failure may occur in practice. Simulations calibrated to error rates from single-cell sequencing data show that an incorrect tree is preferred over the true tree in a substantial fraction of cases (over 50% in some settings) with rates increasing with tree size. Moreover, winning trees are not random but share specific topological features. Notably, at error rates typical of single-cell sequencing data, trees with deeper, more imbalanced topologies are consistently favored over more balanced ones. These results demonstrate that inconsistency is not a theoretical edge case, and that understanding when and how it arises is important when interpreting results in practice. Supplementary MaterialSource code: https://github.com/shahcompbio/phylo_inconsistency FundingThis research was supported in part by NCI SPORE (P50 CA247749-01)

bioinformatics↗

scPlOver: inferring DNA content from amplification-free single-cell WGS using fragment overlaps

Correctly inferring copy-number aberrations from single-cell DNA sequencing data requires estimating cellular DNA content, which is unidentifiable from read counts alone. In tagmentation-based sequencing, each fragment represents a distinct DNA molecule, thus fragment overlaps provide an orthogonal signal for copy number. We present a theoretical model of fragment overlaps as a function of copy number and coverage and introduce scPlOver, a method that uses this model to infer DNA content. scPlOver outperforms existing approaches on simulated and experimental datasets and identifies thousands of ovarian cancer cells with higher DNA content than previously estimated across a cohort of 41 patients.

genomics↗

Evolution of oncogene amplification across 86,000 cancer cell genomes

High-level copy-number (CN) amplification (HLAMP) is a major mechanism of oncogene activation in human cancer. Despite progress in therapeutically targeting amplified oncogenes, the processes underlying amplicon evolution remain incompletely understood, leaving critical knowledge gaps in their etiology and mechanisms of therapeutic response. To address this, we analyzed the evolutionary trajectories of HLAMPs using single-cell whole-genome sequencing data from 86,239 cancer cells across 93 patients and 9 experimental systems. We found that cell-to-cell CN variability provides a quantifiable readout of HLAMP mechanism, clearly distinguishing extrachromosomal circular DNA (ecDNA) from intrachromosomal amplification (ICamp) through characteristic CN distributions that reflect distinct modes of segregation and correspond to clonal architecture. Notably, ICamp events frequently showed multiple amplitude peaks specific to subclones, indicating punctuated shifts in oncogene dosage through numeric or structural modulatory mechanisms with transcriptional impact. In contrast, ecDNAs exhibited broad, continuous CN distribution with extreme high-copy outliers, consistent with asymmetric segregation. The CN and structural diversity of ecDNA regions enabled systematic deconvolution of ecDNA subspecies and estimation of their per-cell abundance, revealing the history of ecDNA-mediated oncogenesis at single-nucleotide resolution. We observed ecDNA diversification through internal rearrangements across cases and, notably, convergent evolution in glioblastoma cases marked by multiple, recurrent acquisition of EGFR-targeting ecDNAs. Finally, single-cell genome-based identification of ecDNAs showed substantial discrepancy with bulk genome graph-based predictions and reliably distinguished actively maintained ecDNAs from historical genomic footprints after chromosomal re-integration. These findings reveal marked tissue-type specificity of ecDNAs, suggesting that ecDNA-mediated oncogenesis may depend on a permissive tissue context.

genomics↗

Inferring active mutational processes in cancer using single cell sequencing and evolutionary constraints

Ongoing mutagenesis in cancer drives genetic diversity throughout the natural history of cancers. As the activities of mutational processes are dynamic throughout evolution, distinguishing the mutational signatures of active and historical processes has important implications for studying how tumors evolve. This can aid in understanding mutagenic states at the time of presentation, and in associating active mutational process with therapeutic resistance. As bulk sequencing primarily captures historical mutational processes, we studied whether ultra-low-coverage single-cell whole-genome sequencing (scWGS), which measures the distribution of mutations across hundreds or thousands of individual cells, could enable the distinction between historical and active mutational processes. While technical challenges and data sparsity have limited mutation analysis in scWGS, we show that these data contain valuable information about dynamic mutational processes. To robustly interpret single nucleotide variants (SNVs) in scWGS, we introduce ArtiCull, a method to identify and remove SNV artifacts by leveraging evolutionary constraints, enabling reliable detection of mutations for signature analysis. Applying this approach to scWGS data from pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC), triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC), and high-grade serous ovarian cancer (HGSOC), we uncover temporal and spatial patterns in mutational processes. In PDAC, we observe a temporal increase in mismatch repair deficiency (MMRd). In cisplatin-treated TNBC patient-derived xenografts, we identify therapy-induced mutagenesis and inactivation of APOBEC3 activity. In HGSOC, we show distinct patterns of APOBEC3 mutagenesis, including late tumor-wide activation in one case and clade-specific enrichment in another. Additionally, we detect a clone-specific increase in SBS17 activity, in a clone previously linked to recurrence. Our findings establish ultra-low-coverage scWGS as a powerful approach for studying active mutational processes that may influence ongoing clonal evolution and therapeutic resistance.

cancer biology↗

Tracking clonal evolution of drug resistance in ovarian cancer patients by exploiting structural variants in cfDNA

Drug resistance is the major cause of therapeutic failure in high-grade serous ovarian cancer (HGSOC). Yet, the mechanisms by which tumors evolve to drug resistant states remains largely unknown. To address this, we aimed to exploit clone-specific genomic structural variations by combining scaled single-cell whole genome sequencing with longitudinally collected cell-free DNA (cfDNA), enabling clonal tracking before, during and after treatment. We developed a cfDNA hybrid capture, deep sequencing approach based on leveraging clone-specific structural variants as endogenous barcodes, with orders of magnitude lower error rates than single nucleotide variants in ctDNA (circulating tumor DNA) detection, demonstrated on 19 patients at baseline. We then applied this to monitor and model clonal evolution over several years in ten HGSOC patients treated with systemic therapy from diagnosis through recurrence. We found drug resistance to be polyclonal in most cases, but frequently dominated by a single high-fitness and expanding clone, reducing clonal diversity in the relapsed disease state in most patients. Drug-resistant clones frequently displayed notable genomic features, including high-level amplifications of oncogenes such as CCNE1, RAB25, NOTCH3, and ERBB2. Using a population genetics Wright-Fisher model, we found evolutionary trajectories of these features were consistent with drug-induced positive selection. In select cases, these alterations impacted selection of secondary lines of therapy with positive patient outcomes. For cases with matched single-cell RNA sequencing data, pre-existing and genomically encoded phenotypic states such as upregulation of EMT and VEGF were linked to drug resistance. Together, our findings indicate that drug resistant states in HGSOC pre-exist at diagnosis and lead to dramatic clonal expansions that alter clonal composition at the time of relapse. We suggest that combining tumor single cell sequencing with cfDNA enables clonal tracking in patients and harbors potential for evolution-informed adaptive treatment decisions.

cancer biology↗

Ongoing genome doubling promotes evolvability and immune dysregulation in ovarian cancer

Whole-genome doubling (WGD) is a critical driver of tumor development and is linked to drug resistance and metastasis in solid malignancies. Here, we demonstrate that WGD is an ongoing mutational process in tumor evolution. Using single-cell whole-genome sequencing, we measured and modeled how WGD events are distributed across cellular populations within tumors and associated WGD dynamics with properties of genome diversification and phenotypic consequences of innate immunity. We studied WGD evolution in 65 high-grade serous ovarian cancer (HGSOC) tissue samples from 40 patients, yielding 29,481 tumor cell genomes. We found near-ubiquitous evidence of WGD as an ongoing mutational process promoting cell-cell diversity, high rates of chromosomal missegregation, and consequent micronucleation. Using a novel mutation-based WGD timing method, doubleTime, we delineated specific modes by which WGD can drive tumor evolution: (i) unitary evolutionary origin followed by significant diversification, (ii) independent WGD events on a pre-existing background of copy number diversity, and (iii) evolutionarily late clonal expansions of WGD populations. Additionally, through integrated single-cell RNA sequencing and high-resolution immunofluorescence microscopy, we found that inflammatory signaling and cGAS-STING pathway activation result from ongoing chromosomal instability and are restricted to tumors that remain predominantly diploid. This contrasted with predominantly WGD tumors, which exhibited significant quiescent and immunosuppressive phenotypic states. Together, these findings establish WGD as an evolutionarily active mutational process that promotes evolvability and dysregulated immunity in late stage ovarian cancer.

cancer biology↗

HATCHet2: clone- and haplotype-specific copy number inference from bulk tumor sequencing data

Multi-region DNA sequencing of primary tumors and metastases from individual patients helps identify somatic aberrations driving cancer development. However, most methods to infer copy-number aberrations (CNAs) analyze individual samples. We introduce HATCHet2 to identify haplotype- and clone-specific CNAs simultaneously from multiple bulk samples. HATCHet2 introduces a novel statistic, the mirrored haplotype B-allele frequency (mhBAF), to identify mirrored-subclonal CNAs having different numbers of copies of parental haplotypes in different tumor clones. HATCHet2 also has high accuracy in identifying focal CNAs and extends the earlier HATCHet method in several directions. We demonstrate HATCHet2s improved accuracy using simulations and a single-cell sequencing dataset. HATCHet2 analysis of 50 prostate cancer samples from 10 patients reveals previously-unreported mirrored-subclonal CNAs affecting cancer genes.

cancer biology↗

The Nonlinear Relations that Predict Influenza Viral Dynamics, CD8+ T cell-Mediated Clearance, Lung Pathology, and Disease Severity

Influenza viruses cause a significant amount of morbidity and mortality. Understanding host immune control efficacy and how different factors influence lung injury and disease severity are critical. Here, we established dynamical connections between viral loads, infected cells, CD8+ T cell-mediated clearance, lung injury, inflammation, and disease severity using an integrative model-experiment exchange. The model was validated through CD8 depletion and whole lung histomorphometry, which showed that the infected area matched the model-predicted infected cell dynamics and that the resolved area paralleled the relative CD8 dynamics. Inflammation could further be predicted by the infected cell dynamics, and additional analyses revealed nonlinear relations between lung injury, inflammation, and disease severity. These links between important pathogen kinetics and host pathology enhance our ability to forecast disease progression, potential complications, and therapeutic efficacy.

microbiology↗

Inferring tumor evolution from longitudinal samples

Background: Determining the clonal composition and somatic evolution of a tumor greatly aids in accurate prognosis and effective treatment for cancer. In order to understand how a tumor evolves over time and/or in response to treatment, multiple recent studies have performed longitudinal DNA sequencing of tumor samples from the same patient at several different time points. However, none of the existing algorithms that infer clonal composition and phylogeny using several bulk tumor samples from the same patient integrate the information that these samples were obtained from longitudinal observations. Results: We introduce a model for a longitudinally-observed phylogeny and derive constraints that longitudinal samples impose on the reconstruction of a phylogeny from bulk samples. These constraints form the basis for a new algorithm, Cancer Analysis of Longitudinal Data through Evolutionary Reconstruction (CALDER), which infers phylogenetic trees from longitudinal bulk DNA sequencing data. We show on simulated data that constraints from longitudinal sampling can substantially reduce ambiguity when deriving a phylogeny from multiple bulk tumor samples, each a mixture of tumor clones. On real data, where there is often considerable uncertainty in the clonal composition of a sample, longitudinal constraints yield more parsimonious phylogenies with fewer tumor clones per sample. We demonstrate that CALDER reconstructs more plausible phylogenies than existing methods on two longitudinal DNA sequencing datasets from chronic lymphocytic leukemia patients. These findings show the advantages of directly incorporating temporal information from longitudinal sampling into tumor evolution studies. Availability: CALDER is available at https://github.com/raphael-group.

bioinformatics↗