Ionizable Lipids Promote Curvature Remodeling and Altered Fluctuation Dynamics in Endosomal Membranes
Inefficient endosomal escape is a crucial barrier to intracellular delivery of nucleic acid therapeutics using lipid nanoparticles (LNPs). The use of ionizable lipids (ILs) has significantly improved cargo delivery efficiency, yet the physical basis of their interaction with endosomal membranes and their role in endosomal escape remain unclear. It has been suggested that, as ILs become cationic during endosomal acidification, electrostatic affinity promotes fusion of the LNPs with the endosome. In this paper, we propose an additional mechanism in which ILs are redistributed from LNPs to host membranes, modulating the elastic properties and curvature of the membrane, lowering the energetic threshold for endosome disruption. To test this, we quantified the spontaneous curvature of clinically relevant ILs and ATP-binding lipids and measured the membrane mechanics of giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) with an endosome-relevant composition at endosome-relevant pH. Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) measurements reveal that the incorporation of ILs and ATP lipids into endosome-mimetic membranes shifts the spontaneous curvature towards more negative values. Micropipette aspiration experiments indicated a decrease in the apparent area compressibility modulus of membranes doped with ILs and ATP lipids. In addition, membranes showed enhanced fluctuation amplitudes and altered relaxation behavior, consistent with membrane perturbations associated with lipid insertion and pH- or ATP-driven destabilization. Under conditions promoting the partitioning of ILs or ATP-binding lipids, we further observed reduced bending rigidity and increased heterogeneity in membrane tension. Together, these results support a model in which ILs (as well as newly developed ATP-binding lipids) partition into endosomal membranes, softening the membrane and generating local curvature frustration that facilitates endosomal disruption during the natural acidification process. By quantitatively linking lipid composition with changes in membrane elasticity and fluctuation dynamics, this work provides a biophysical framework for understanding how lipid redistribution may contribute to endosomal escape and improve delivery efficiency.