Rare twin cysteine residues in the HIV-1 envelope variable region 1 link to neutralization escape and breadth development
The identification of HIV-1 Envelope glycoprotein (Env) traits associated with development of neutralization cross-reactivity in natural infection is critical for vaccine design. Here we describe the presence of additional Cysteine (Cys) residues in V1 that are enriched among people with elite neutralization breadth. Using >65,000 V1 sequences from the CATNAP database, the AMP trials and three large longitudinal HIV infection cohorts, the SHCS, ZPHI and CAPRISA studies, we show that Env variants with extra V1 Cys are present at low levels throughout infection and fluctuate in frequency over time within participants. We demonstrate an independent association of extra V1 Cys with elite plasma neutralization, and a strong preference for two versus one extra Cys, suggesting certain Envs introduce an additional disulfide bond for stabilization. We observed high levels of neutralization resistance among Envs from 34 bNAb donors, of which 17.6% had elongated V1 regions with extra Cys. We show that extra V1 Cys moderately increase neutralization resistance in an Env from a V2- Apex bNAb-inducer. Modulation of the accessibility of bNAb epitopes on this Env by extra V1 Cys enhanced epitope shielding of several regions, but increased V2 exposure. This suggests that escape from autologous neutralizing activity drove insertion of the extra V1 Cys, creating a modified antigen that may have favored V2 bNAb induction in this donor. Overall, we identify a rare motif of twin Cys in V1 that confers increased neutralization resistance and Env stabilization, is associated with bNAb induction, and may hold potential for incorporation into future HIV bNAb immunogens.