bioRxiv Science⌕ Search

Biology subjects

Kimball, J.

Publications and source records attributed to Kimball, J..

7 recordsLinked to original sources

Single-Plant Genome-Wide Association Study Identifies Loci Controlling Multiple Vegetative Architecture Traits in Cultivated Northern Wild Rice (Zizania palustris L.)

Cultivated Northern Wild Rice (Zizania palustris L.) is an obligately outcrossing, self-incompatible cereal grown in aquatic paddies in the United States. Genetic improvement has relied primarily on phenotypic recurrent selection, and genomic approaches remain largely unexplored in this emerging crop. We applied a single-plant genome-wide association study (sp-GWAS) framework to dissect vegetative architecture traits in five open-pollinated cultivated populations evaluated across three years (n = 2,173 plants). Plant height (PH), basal stem width (BSW), primary stem width (PSW), flag leaf length (FLL), and flag leaf width (FLW) were analyzed using a mixed linear model accounting for population structure and kinship. Broad-sense heritability ranged from 0.03 to 0.34, and year effects explained up to 54% of phenotypic variance, indicating strong environmental influence. After filtering 73,363 SNPs, genome-wide linkage disequilibrium decayed rapidly (r{superscript 2} = 0.1 at [~]2.3 kb). A total of 124 significant SNPs (FDR < 0.01) were consolidated into 98 loci, of which 46 were associated with multiple traits and 11 were shared across four traits. Candidate genes near multi-trait loci included conserved regulatory classes implicated in grass architecture, including HLH/bHLH transcription factors. Diplotype analyses at candidate loci revealed both simple biallelic and complex multi-allelic haplotype structures, indicating that locus-level haplotype effects underlie several GWAS signals. Results demonstrate that sp-GWAS can detect statistically robust associations in a highly heterozygous, non-replicable crop system and suggest a polygenic, coordinated genetic architecture governing vegetative growth. These findings support genomic prediction and multi-trait selection strategies to accelerate improvement of cultivated Northern Wild Rice. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARYCultivated Northern Wild Rice is an important specialty crop grown in flooded paddies in the United States. Unlike many major crops, it is naturally outcrossing and highly variable, which makes traditional breeding challenging and slow. Most improvement efforts have relied on selecting plants based only on how they look in the field, and genomic tools have rarely been used. In this study, we used DNA markers to better understand the genetics behind plant structure traits such as plant height, stem thickness, and leaf width. We evaluated more than 2,000 plants from five cultivated populations over three growing seasons. Because weather and growing conditions strongly influence these traits, we used statistical models to separate environmental effects from genetic effects. We identified 98 regions of the genome associated with variation in plant structure. Many of these regions influenced more than one trait, showing that plant height, stem strength, and leaf size are genetically connected. Several regions contained genes similar to those known to control plant growth and development in other grasses. We also found that, in some cases, combinations of nearby DNA variants (haplotypes) explained trait differences better than single genetic markers. Overall, this work shows that modern genomic tools can successfully identify useful genetic variation in cultivated Northern Wild Rice, even though it is highly outcrossing and genetically diverse. These results provide a foundation for using genomic selection to improve plant structure, lodging resistance, and overall performance in breeding programs. CORE IDEASO_LISingle-plant GWAS successfully detects genetic associations in obligately outcrossing cultivated Northern Wild Rice where conventional replicated mapping populations are impractical. C_LIO_LIVegetative architecture traits exhibit low heritability but retain recoverable polygenic signal, where nearly half of detected loci influence multiple architecture traits, indicating integrated developmental control. C_LIO_LIGenome-wide linkage disequilibrium decays rapidly ([~]2.3 kb), consistent with expectations for an obligately outcrossing species and supporting relatively localized association signals. C_LIO_LICandidate genes include conserved regulatory classes (TE1-like, HLH/bHLH, SPL). C_LIO_LIGiven extensive overlap between QTL and environmental effect, multi-trait, multi-environment genomic prediction provides a pragmatic breeding strategy to improve canopy efficiency, lodging resistance, and harvestability in aquatic production systems. C_LI

genomics↗

Transcriptional architecture underlying development, adaptation, and domestication in Northern Wild Rice (Zizania palustris L.)

AO_SCPLOWBSTRACTC_SCPLOWZizania palustris (Northern Wild Rice) is an aquatic grass native to North America and a crop wild relative of Oryza sativa with ecological, cultural, and agricultural significance. Here, we present a transcriptomic atlas spanning 20 tissues across six major developmental stages. Seed tissues showed shifts in abscisic acid, gibberellin, and ethylene pathways that define the hormonal basis of deep dormancy in this recalcitrant species and its release. Leaf development showed stage-specific reprogramming, from hypoxia-responsive programs in submerged tissues to cell wall remodeling and redox regulation during aquatic-aerial transitions, with photosynthesis and carbohydrate metabolism defining flag leaves and SRG1 divergence emerging as a defining feature of leaf development in Z. palustris. Reproductive tissues expressed duplicated homologs of well-recognized shattering genes with divergent regulation, consistent with subfunctionalization after whole-genome duplication. These findings provide new insight into traits underlying ecological adaptation and domestication in Z. palustris and related grasses. CORE IDEASO_LIA first transcriptomic atlas for Northern Wild Rice maps gene expression across 20 tissues and six developmental stages, providing a foundational functional genomics resource for Zizania palustris. C_LIO_LISeed dormancy and release are driven by coordinated hormone reprogramming, with shifts in ABA, GA, and ethylene pathways across whole seed, embryo, and endosperm. C_LIO_LILeaf development is defined by aquatic-to-aerial transcriptional transitions, moving from hypoxia-responsive programs in submerged tissues to cell wall remodeling, redox regulation, and photosynthesis/metabolism in aerial and flag leaves. C_LIO_LIWhole-genome duplication underlies regulatory divergence in domestication traits, as duplicated homologs of canonical seed shattering genes show paralog- and tissue-specific expression consistent with subfunctionalization. C_LIO_LIThe atlas identifies tissue-specific modules and stable housekeeping candidates, enabling improved experimental design (e.g., expression normalization) and accelerating candidate prioritization for breeding, GWAS/eQTL, and trait discovery. C_LI PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARYNorthern Wild Rice (Zizania palustris) is an aquatic grass native to North America that is important for ecosystems, agriculture, and Indigenous cultures. In this study, we created a detailed gene expression map across 20 different tissues and six stages of plant development. We found that seeds strongly regulate plant hormones that control dormancy, helping explain why Northern Wild Rice seeds remain dormant for long periods and how they eventually germinate. Leaves showed clear changes in gene activity as plants moved from underwater growth to above-water growth, shifting from low-oxygen stress responses to processes that support photosynthesis and structural strength. In flowers, we identified duplicated genes involved in seed shattering that are regulated differently, likely due to past genome duplication events. Together, these results improve our understanding of how Northern Wild Rice is adapted to aquatic environments and how key traits relevant to domestication have evolved.

plant biology↗

Investigating experimental storage methodologies for the understudied intermediate recalcitrant seed of Northern Wild Rice (Zizania palustris L.)

The maintenance of plant genetic diversity is an essential target for conservation and breeding efforts. However, the ability to store seed varies between species with those that are more easily stored being overrepresented in seed banks. Northern Wild Rice (NWR; Zizania palustris) has intermediately recalcitrant seed which, along with its dormancy period, makes it more challenging to store long term. This study evaluated alternate storage treatments, including water changes, aeration, and the shift from submerged to moist seed, to extend the longevity of NWR seed in storage compared to current best management practices. Monthly water changes were the most effective storage treatment, maintaining greater than [~] 50% viability for over 28 months. There was a negative correlation found between aerated treatments with high dissolved oxygen and seed viability. Submerged to moist storage was only effective for [~]16 months. Control treatments maintained relatively high viability ([&ge;] 58%) through 21 months of storage. However, by 28 months, monthly water change seed had significantly higher viability (57.6%) compared to either the standard control (37.2%) or the bucket control (28.9%), suggesting that this treatment is more efficacious than standard storage conditions for maintaining seed viability of NWR.

plant biology↗

Genetic Analysis of Wild and Cultivated Populations of Northern Wild Rice (Zizania palustris L.) Reveal New Insights into Gene Flow and Domestication

Northern Wild Rice (NWR; Zizania palustris L.) is an aquatic, annual grass with significant ecological, cultural, and economic importance to the Great Lakes region of North America. In this study, we assembled and genotyped a diverse collection of 839 NWR individuals using genotyping-by-sequencing (GBS) and obtained 5,955 single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). Our collection consisted of samples from 12 wild NWR populations collected across Minnesota and Western Wisconsin, some of which were collected over two time points; a representative collection of cultivated NWR varieties and breeding populations; and a Zizania aquatica outgroup. Using these data, we characterized the genetic diversity, relatedness, and population structure of this broad collection of NWR genotypes. We found that wild populations of NWR clustered primarily by their geographical location, with some clustering patterns likely influenced by historical ecosystem management. Cultivated populations were genetically distinct from wild populations, suggesting limited gene flow between the semi-domesticated crop and its wild counterparts. The first genome-wide scans of putative selection events in cultivated NWR suggest that the crop is undergoing heavy selection pressure for traits conducive to irrigated paddy conditions. Overall, this study presents a large set of SNP markers for use in NWR genetic studies and provides new insights into the gene flow, history, and complexity of wild and cultivated populations of NWR.

genetics↗

Spatiotemporal Profiling of Seed-Associated Microbes of an Aquatic, Intermediate Recalcitrant Species, Zizania palustris L. and the Impact of Anti-Microbial Seed Treatments

Northern wild rice (NWR; Zizania palustris var. interior) (NWR) is an ecologically important, annual, aquatic species native to North America, that is also cultivated in irrigated paddies in Minnesota and California. NWR seeds are desiccation-sensitive and must be kept in hydrated conditions, in which viability can decline rapidly within the first two years of storage. During this period, microbial growth is rampant and the relationship between these communities and the viability of NWR seed is unclear. In this study, we cultured and identified bacteria and fungi found in 27 NWR seed stocks, collected over a five-year period from three locations and four NWR genotypes. Results revealed that microbial communities were heavily dependent on seed viability and communities began shifting after one year of seed storage. Fungi became more prominent as years in storage increased suggesting that fungi begin to outcompete bacteria. Spatial analysis of locations and genotypes revealed a core set of microbes found across locations and genotypes. Penicillium and Pseudomonas were ubiquitous in NWR hydrated seed storage. We also evaluated the efficacy of four antimicrobial treatments at reducing microbial growth in hydrated NWR seed storage. These treatments did not reduce or drastically change microbial growth or seed viability. However, previously undetected microbes were identified after treatments, which suggested a disruption to the major constituents of the microbiome. Overall, this study identified common microbial constituents found in an aquatic, recalcitrant species, adapted for a cold climate, during seed storage and provides a foundation for future studies to evaluate the effect of microbial communities on NWR seed viability during hydrated storage.

plant biology↗

Dormancy Breaking Treatments in Northern Wild Rice (Zizania palustris L.) Seed Suggest a Physiological Source of Dormancy

Dormancy is a limiting factor for breeding in northern wild rice (NWR; Zizania palustris L). This study developed a dormancy curve and tested a combination of scarification and hormone treatments, across three timepoints, for their ability to break dormancy in NWR and produce viable seedlings and plants. A dormancy curve was established across 9 months post-harvest, which showed maximum germination (95%) by 17 weeks post-harvest and high germination ([&ge;]81 %) through the rest of the testing period. Next, dormancy breaking treatments were tested. At 1 week post-harvest, few seeds germinated ([&le;] 15 %) across all treatment combinations. However, sulfuric acid increased germination shortly after harvest (5.8 %), compared to water (0.5 %) and NaClO (0 %) but resulted in stunted seedlings, all but one of which died shortly thereafter. At 7 weeks, sulfuric acid treated seeds did not result in significantly higher germination than water and maximum germination was still below 15%. By 11 weeks post-harvest, the water treatments had the highest germination and resulted in the most viable plants, indicating that dormancy had begun to break naturally and exceeded the effect of the other scarification treatments. Hormonal treatments had no significant effect on germination or seed viability and no strong conclusions could be drawn about their effect on seedling or plant health. Due to the inability of early germinated seed to consistently produce viable plants and the increase in germination following sufficient cold storage, it is likely that NWR seed has intermediate or deep physiological dormancy.

plant biology↗

Evaluation of a Recessive Male Floret Color in Cultivated Northern Wild Rice (Zizania palustris L.) for Pollen-Mediated Gene Flow Studies

Northern wild rice (NWR; Zizania palustris L.) is a wind-pollinated, annual, aquatic grass that grows naturally in the Great Lakes Region (GLR) of the United States and Canada, and is also cultivated in flooded paddies, predominantly in California and Minnesota. A better understanding of pollen-mediated gene flow is needed within the species for both conservation and breeding efforts as cultivation occurs within the species natural range and spatially-isolated, paddy structures are limited within breeding programs. Widely cited pollen travel research in NWR demonstrated that pollen could travel at least 3200m. However, a population segregating for male sterility was used as the pollen recipient in the study and was determined to not be adequate for NWR pollen travel studies. Here, we present the characterization of a recessive white male floret (WMF) population in contrast to the dominant, purple male floret (PMF) color of cultivated NWR along with estimates of pollen-mediated gene flow in a cultivated paddy setting. Studies conducted in 2018 and 2019 revealed that the primary amount of pollen-mediated gene flow occurred within the first 7m from the PMF donor source with no gene flow detected past 63m. These results suggest that the likelihood of pollen-mediated gene flow between cultivated NWR and natural stands remains low. We also identified a strong linkage between male floret, auricle, and culm color. This study demonstrates that the WMF trait is an excellent candidate for use in pollen-mediated gene flow studies in NWR.

plant biology↗