Effects of Instructional Context on Neural Features of Attention during Learning Activities in Children with and without ADHD
Attention is foundational to learning, yet the extent to which features of the instructional environment differentially shape attentional engagement is not well understood. Here we leveraged mobile EEG and video-coded behavioral observation to examine attentional engagement in 6 to 10 years old children with and without a diagnosis of ADHD across instructional conditions varying in delivery modality (video watching, online, in-person) and management of learning (teacher-led versus student-led). EEG measures, including alpha-band (8-12Hz) oscillations, spectral slope and offset, and behavioral measures of active engagement (AE%), passive engagement (PE%), fidgeting, off-task behavior, were examined as a function of instructional context. Attentional engagement, as indicated by higher AE%, lower alpha power, flatter spectral slope and lower offset, was greatest in student-led learning, followed by teacher-led in person learning, synchronous online learning, and asynchronous learning, respectively. Child by instructional context interactions revealed that patterns of attentional engagement were largely consistent regardless of diagnosis, with group effects observed for motor behaviors (PE%, fidgeting) but not for measures of visual attention. Similarly, age showed only main effects, whereby older children showed higher passive engagement, lower fidgeting and off-task behavior, flatter spectral slope, and lower offset. The results underscore: (i) the importance of considering environmental context, such as instructional modality and management of learning, when examining mechanisms of attention and individual differences therein, and (ii) the value of recording multiple behavioral and neural measures, as not all indices commonly assumed to reflect attention capture the same underlying processes.