Kaarlejärvi, E. | bioRxiv Science

bioRxiv2022

Diverging trends and drivers of Arctic flower production over space and time

The Arctic is warming at an alarming rate. While changes in plant community composition and phenology have been extensively reported, the effects of climate change on reproduction remain poorly understood. We quantified multidecadal changes in flower density for nine tundra plant species at a low- and a high-arctic site in Greenland. We found substantial changes in flower density over time, but the temporal trends and drivers of flower density differed both between species and sites. Total flower density increased over time at the low-arctic site, whereas the high-arctic site showed no directional change. Within and between sites, the direction and rate of change differed among species, with varying effects of summer temperature, the temperature of the previous autumn and the timing of snowmelt. Finally, all species showed a strong trade-off in flower densities between successive years, suggesting an effective cost of reproduction. Overall, our results reveal region-and taxon-specific variation in the sensitivity and responses of co-occurring species to shared climatic drivers, and a clear cost of reproductive investment among arctic plants. The ultimate effects of further changes in climate may thus be decoupled between species and across space, with critical knock-on effects on plant species dynamics, food web structure and overall ecosystem functioning.

ecology↗

bioRxiv2022

Identifying and separating the processes underlying boreal forest understory community assembly

Joint species distribution models (JSDMs) are an important conservation tool for predicting ecosystem diversity and function under global change. The growing complexity of modern JSDMs necessitates careful model selection tailored to the challenges of community prediction under novel conditions (i.e., transferable models). Common approaches to evaluate the performance of JSDMs for community-level prediction are based on individual species predictions that do not account for the species correlation structures inherent in JSDMs. Here, we formalize a Bayesian model selection approach that accounts for species correlation structures and apply it to compare the community-level predictive performance of alternative JSDMs across broad environmental gradients emulating transferable applications. We connect the evaluation of JSDM predictions to Bayesian model selection theory under which the log score is the preferred performance measure for probabilistic prediction. We define the joint log score for community-level prediction and distinguish it from more commonly applied JSDM evaluation metrics. We then apply this community log score to evaluate predictions of 1,918 out-of-sample boreal forest understory communities spanning 39 species generated using a novel JSDM framework that supports alternative species correlation structures: independent, compositional dependence, and residual dependence. The best performing JSDM included all observed environmental variables and multinomial species correlations reflecting compositional dependence within modeled community data. The addition of flexible residual species correlations improved model predictions only within JSDMs applying a reduced set of environmental variables highlighting potential confounding between unobserved environmental conditions and residual species dependence. The best performing JSDM was consistent across successional and bio-climatic gradients regardless of whether interest was in species- or community-level prediction. Our study demonstrates the utility of the community log score to quantify differences in the predictive performance of complex JSDMs and highlights the importance of accounting for species dependence when interest is in community composition under novel conditions.

ecology↗