bioRxiv Science⌕ Search

Biology subjects

Herreros, D.

Publications and source records attributed to Herreros, D..

7 recordsLinked to original sources

Ab initio CryoEM maps minimizing preferred orientation problems in heterogeneous mixtures: ReconSIREN

Cryo-Electron Microscopy (CryoEM) Single Particle Analysis (SPA) is pivotal for elucidating protein structures and their conformational dynamics. Several critical steps are required to obtain accurate maps. First, the \textit{ab initio} relative orientations and shifts between images must be determined. Second, the common issue of specimens presenting a preferred orientation should be adequately addressed. Third, all of the above must account for particle flexibility and sample heterogeneity. Additionally, these steps are interrelated, making the search for all these parameters a real challenge when considering convergence robustness. In this context, we present ReconSIREN, a novel deep learning framework that addresses the key steps outlined before in an \textit{ab initio} manner while greatly minimizing one of the most important practical burdens in SPA, namely the errors introduced in the CryoEM maps by the existence of preferred orientations; the latter is achieved by a change of the optimization approach that avoids the so-called ``attraction problem'', and by the introduction of a new type of geometrical priors. It does so fully \textit{ab initio}, using deep learning training/inference steps without resorting to more traditional optimization approaches, and generating highly accurate initial reconstructions. We present maps as both homogeneous (consensus) maps and a full conformational landscape for analyzing flexibility and heterogeneity. Thanks to its Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) architecture, ReconSIREN distributes the estimation workload across independent experts, improving optimization efficiency and simplifying the process.

bioinformatics↗

Improving Cryo-EM Optimization Robustness with an Optimal Transport Loss Function for Noisy Images

Many tasks in single-particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM), such as 2D/3D classification and homo/heterogeneous reconstruction, require optimizing model parameters to minimize the discrepancy between observed data and a forward model. The standard Mean Squared Error (MSE) loss function is computationally efficient but suffers from a non-convex rugged loss landscape, particularly for high-resolution heterogeneity inference. In this work, we investigate the practical utility of Sliced Wasserstein (SW) distances. We implement exact W2 estimators (inverse-CDF and greedy matching) of projections alongside a computationally efficient proxy based on the L2 norm of CDFs, a formulation akin to the sliced Cramer-von Mises distance. We establish the latter as a robust, fully differentiable workhorse for the cryo-EM forward model. We evaluate its performance against the MSE in joint inference tasks recovering pose, CTF parameters, and conformational heterogeneity. Our results demonstrate that SW significantly broadens the basin of attraction, enabling robust gradient-based optimization from distant initializations where MSE fails. Using a helical spiral toy model, we highlight how SW losses are sensitive to per-particle contrast, where background noise level miscalibration can induce geometric bias in the inferred structure. We show that this bias is manageable through a joint optimization strategy that treats background contrast as a learnable parameter. Finally, we validate the approach on a synthetic dataset using the Zernike3D framework, showing that the SW loss works and yields an accurate landscape representations, comparable with MSE. These findings establish SW as a powerful tool for navigating the rugged landscapes of cryo-EM forward model parameters. SynopsisThe Sliced Wasserstein loss provides a smoother optimization landscapes than mean squared error for single particle cryo-EM joint inference of pose, CTF defocus and conformational heterogeneity. Estimating background contrast is essential to avoid biasing other parameters.

molecular biology↗

The Inaugural Flatiron Institute Cryo-EM Conformational Heterogeneity Challenge

Despite the rise of single particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) as a premier method for resolving macromolecular structures at atomic resolution, methods to address molecular heterogeneity in vitrified samples have yet to reach maturity. With an increasing number of new methods to analyze the multitude of heterogeneous states captured in single particle images, a systematic approach to validation in this field is needed. With this motivation, we issued a challenge to the community to analyze two cryo-EM particle image sets of thyroglobulin that exhibit continuous conformational heterogeneity. The first dataset was experimental and the second was generated with a simulator, allowing control over the distribution of molecular structures and enabled direct comparison between participants submissions and the ground truth molecular structures and distributions. Participants were asked to submit 80 volumes representing the heterogeneous ensemble and estimate their respective populations in the image sets provided. Participation of the research community in the challenge was strong, with submissions from nearly all developers of heterogeneity methods, resulting in 41 submissions across both datasets. Submissions qualitatively exceeded expectations, with the molecular motions identified by methods resembling both each other and the ground truth motion. However, quantitatively assessing these similarities was a challenge in and of itself. In the process of assessing the submissions, we developed several validation metrics, most of which require reference to the underlying ground truth volumes. However, we have also explored the use of metrics that do not necessarily reference ground truth. This is particularly apt for experimental datasets where ground truth is inaccessible. These approaches allowed us to assess the similarity and accuracy in volume quality, molecular motions, and conformational distribution of di!erent submissions. These metrics and the e!orts of all participants help chart a path forward for the improvements of heterogeneity methods for cryo-EM and for future challenges to validate these new methods as they continue to be developed by the community.

biophysics↗

How many (distinguishable) classes can we identify in Single Particle Analysis?

Heterogeneity in cryoEM is essential for capturing macromolecule structural variability, reflecting their functional states and biological significance. However, estimating heterogeneity remains challenging due to particle misclassification and algorithmic biases, which can lead to reconstructions that blend distinct conformations or fail to resolve subtle differences. Furthermore, the low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) inherent in cryo-EM data makes it nearly impossible to detect minute structural changes, as noise often obscures subtle variations in macromolecular projections. In this paper, we investigate the use of p-values associated with the null hypothesis that the observed classification differs from a random partition of the input dataset, thereby providing a statistical framework for determining the number of distinguishable classes present in a given dataset.

molecular biology↗

Merging conformational landscapes in a single consensus space with FlexConsensus algorithm

The analysis of structural heterogeneity in CryoEM is experimenting a significant breakthrough toward estimating more accurate, richer, and interpretable conformational landscapes directly derived from experimental data. The increasing number of new methods designed to tackle the heterogeneity challenge reflects these new paradigms, allowing users to understand protein dynamics better. However, a question remains on how the estimation of different heterogeneity algorithms compare, which is essential to properly determine the reliability, stability, and correctness of the conformational landscapes and the structural transitions extracted from the CryoEM images. The intrinsic differences arising from the approximation and implementation of every heterogeneity algorithm make the definition of a consensus complex, a problem that remains unsolved. To overcome the challenges of comparing heterogeneity algorithms, we introduce our new FlexConsenus algorithm in this work. FlexConsensus relies on a multi-autoencoder architecture to learn the commonalities and differences of several conformational landscapes, allowing one to place them in a shared consensus space with enhanced reliability. In addition, FlexConsensus enables the derivation of error metrics from the consensus space to measure the reproducibility of the heterogeneity estimations. Thanks to the previous consensus metrics, it is possible to clean the original particle datasets further based on the differences in the estimation of their structural variability among different algorithms and/or different runs, allowing users to focus their analysis only on those particles with a stable estimation of their structural variability.

bioinformatics↗

Real-space heterogeneous reconstruction, refinement, and disentanglement of CryoEM conformational states with HetSIREN

Single-particle analysis by Cryo-electron microscopy (CryoEM) provides direct access to the conformation of each macromolecule. However, the images signal-to-noise ratio is low, and some form of classification is usually performed at the image processing level to allow structural modeling. Classical classification methods imply the existence of a discrete number of structural conformations. However, new heterogeneity algorithms introduce a novel reconstruction paradigm, where every state is represented by a lower number of particles, potentially just one, allowing the estimation of conformational landscapes representing the different structural states a biomolecule explores. In this work, we present a novel deep learning-based method called HetSIREN. HetSIREN can fully reconstruct or refine a CryoEM volume in real space based on the structural information summarized in a conformational latent space. The unique characteristics that set HetSIREN apart start with the definition of the approach as a real space-based only method, a fact that allows spatially focused analysis, but also the introduction of a novel network architecture specifically designed to make use of meta-sinusoidal activations, with proven high analytics capacities. Continuing with innovations, HetSIREN can also refine the pose parameters of the images at the same time that it conditions the network with prior information/constraints on the maps, such as Total Variation and L1 denoising, ultimately yielding cleaner volumes with high-quality structural features. Finally, but very importantly, HetSIREN addresses one of the most confusing issues in heterogeneity analysis, as it is the fact that real structural heterogeneity estimation is entangled with pose estimation (and to a lesser extent with CTF estimation), in this way, HetSIREN introduces a novel encoding architecture able to decouple pose and CTF information from the conformational landscape, resulting in more accurate and interpretable conformational latent spaces. We present results on computer-simulated data, public data from EMPIAR, and data from experimental systems currently being studied in our laboratories. An important finding is the sensitivity of the structure and dynamics of the SARS-CoV-2 Spike protein on the storage temperature.

bioinformatics↗

Improvements on marker-free images alignment for electron tomography

Electron tomography is a technique to obtain three-dimensional structural information of samples. However, the technique is limited by shifts occurring during acquisition that need to be corrected before the reconstruction process. In 2009, we proposed an approach for post-acquisition alignment of tilt series images. This approach was marker-free, based on patch tracking and integrated in free software. Here, we present improvements to the method to make it more reliable, stable and accurate. In addition, we modified the image formation model underlying the alignment procedure to include different deformations occurring during acquisition. We propose a new way to correct these computed deformations to obtain reconstructions with reduced artifacts. The new approach has demonstrated to improve the quality of the final 3D reconstruction, giving access to better defined structures for different transmission electron tomography methods: resin embedded STEM-tomography and cryo-TEM tomography. The method is freely available in TomoJ software.

molecular biology↗