bioRxiv Science⌕ Search

Biology subjects

Hepburn, C.

Publications and source records attributed to Hepburn, C..

2 recordsLinked to original sources

Environmental DNA reflects common haplotypic variation

Analysis of environmental DNA (eDNA) has gained widespread usage for taxonomically based biodiversity assessment. While interest in applying non-invasive eDNA monitoring for population genetic assessments has grown, its usage in this sphere remains limited. One barrier to uptake is that the effectiveness of eDNA detection below the species level remains to be determined for multiple species and environments. Here, we test the utility of this emergent technology in a population genetic framework using eDNA samples derived from water along New Zealands South Island (Otago Coast: n=9; Kaik[o]ura: n=7) and DNA obtained from tissue samples (n=76) of individual blackfoot p[a]ua (Haliotis iris) sampled from New Zealands Otago coast. We recovered four mitochondrial haplotypes from eDNA versus six from the tissue samples collected. Three common haplotypes were recovered with both eDNA and tissue samples, while only one out of three rare haplotypes - represented in tissue samples by one individual each - was recovered with our eDNA methods. We demonstrate that eDNA monitoring is an effective tool for recovering common genetic diversity from p[a]ua, although rare (< 5%) haplotypes are seldom recovered. Our results show the potential of eDNA to identify population-level haplotypes for gastropods in the marine environment identification below the species level and for studying the population genetic diversity of gastropods. This work supports eDNA methods as effective, non-invasive tools for genetic monitoring. Non-invasive eDNA sampling could minimize target organism stress and human interaction enabling population genetic research for hard-to-sample, delicate, or sensitive species.

genetics↗

Environmental DNA analysis needs local reference data to inform taxonomy-based conservation policy:A case study from Aotearoa / New Zealand

Effective management of biodiversity requires regular surveillance of multiple species. Analysis of environmental DNA by metabarcoding (eDNA) holds promise to achieve this relatively easily. However, taxonomic inquiries into eDNA data need suitable molecular reference data, which are often lacking. We evaluate the impact of this reference data void in a case study of fish diversity in the remote fiords of New Zealand. We compared eDNA-derived species identifications against Baited Remote Underwater Video (BRUV) data collected at the same time and locations as the eDNA data. Furthermore, we cross referenced both eDNA and BRUV data against species lists for the same region obtained from literature surveys and the Ocean Biodiversity Information System (OBIS). From all four data sources, we obtained a total of 116 species records (106 ray-finned fishes, 10 cartilaginous fishes; 59 from literature, 44 from eDNA, 25 from BRUV, 25 from OBIS). Concordance of taxonomies between the data sources dissolved with lowering taxonomic levels, most decisively so for eDNA data. BRUV agreed with local biodiversity information much better and fared better in detecting regional biodiversity dissimilarities. We provide evidence that eDNA metabarcoding will remain a powerful but impaired tool for species-level biodiversity management without locally generated reference data.

ecology↗