The environmental impact of pharmaceuticals: an evidence-mapping review of recent data on aquatic concentrations and predictable effects
Pharmaceuticals are recognised among emerging contaminants, particularly in water. They have the potential to alter ecosystem dynamics, with notable examples including hormone-induced feminization of male fish and disruptions to oogenesis in invertebrates. To assess the risk posed by pharmaceuticals, it is essential to understand their amount (via Measured Environmental Concentrations - MEC) and their actual effects on target species (via Predicted No Effect Concentrations - PNEC). Recently, many studies have aimed to collect MEC data from around the world, but a comprehensive overview is still lacking. Thus, the objective of this study is to provide a comprehensive overview by examining recently published literature on MEC data for a wide range of pharmaceuticals. Additionally, to enable risk assessment, this study also reviewed the published literature on PNEC data and integrated it with existing databases. A total of 315 substances were selected for MEC data extraction, with the inclusion of 56 articles. The most frequently monitored locations were Cadiz Bay in Spain (90 samples), the River Thames in the UK (51), and Hrd[e]jovice in the Czech Republic (49). Most MEC samples were collected from surface water (N=325), influent wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) (205), and effluent WWTP (118). Based on PNEC values, risk analysis identified 81 pharmaceuticals as high-risk, with the highest risk values for propranolol (risk quotient [RQ]: 29,450,000), diclofenac (395,920), and 17alpha-ethinylestradiol (95,946). Additionally, the ATC classes with the most high-risk substances were anti-infectives (J), nervous system agents (N), cardiovascular agents (C), antineoplastic agents (L), analgesics (M), and sex hormones (G). The findings of this study highlight the widespread impact of pharmaceuticals across the globe and the involvement of multiple therapeutic classes. To move beyond the current point-in-time overview, which is limited to specific locations and sampling periods, systems for continuous monitoring of pharmaceuticals should be developed. This could involve the creation of resource-efficient methods and the integration of sampling data with estimation models. Furthermore, these results could serve as a starting point for developing and implementing actions to prevent and mitigate the environmental impact of pharmaceuticals.