Biology subjects

Debelius, J. W.

Publications and source records attributed to Debelius, J. W..

4 recordsLinked to original sources

bioRxiv2025

In harmony? A scoping review of methods to combine multiple 16S amplicon data sets

Robust evidence on relationships between the human microbiome and health are critical for understanding and improving the human condition. However, there is little information about methodological approaches to combine and analyze multiple microbiome data sets. To address this gap, we conducted a scoping review of studies that combine sequencing data from multiple data sets to understand the study objectives, data sources and selection, feature -table assembly methods, and analyses. References were identified through a systematic search of literature published between 2011 and 2022. Our final review included 60 articles. Despite the wide-spread use of the word "meta-analysis," we found that only 24 studies used a systematic process to select their data sets, suggesting multiple meanings of the term within the field. While more than two thirds of studies used at least one publicly available data source, 19 had to request data from the original authors. Most studies (60%) combined data sets from multiple disjoint hypervariable regions. The number of hypervariable regions combined was not associated with the table construction method, but feature table construction method and the number of hypervariable regions influenced analytical resolution. Our results suggest the microbiome community needs to examine the use of terminology and analytic approaches for combining data sets; that additional work is needed to explore the impact of data source on bias in combined studies; and invite an independent evaluation of the methods used for feature table construction across disjoint regions.

microbiology↗

bioRxiv2021

A comparison of approaches to scaffolding multiple regions along the 16S rRNA gene for improved resolution

MotivationFull length, high resolution 16s rRNA marker gene sequencing has been challenging historically. Short amplicons provide high accuracy reads with widely available equipment, at the cost of taxonomic resolution. One recent proposal has been to reconstruct multiple amplicons along the full-length marker gene, however no barcode-free computationally tractable approach for this is available. To address this gap, we present Sidle (SMURF Implementation Done to acceLerate Efficiency), an implementation of the Short MUltiple Reads Framework algorithm with a novel tree building approach to reconstruct rRNA genes from individually amplified regions. ResultsUsing simulated and real data, we compared Sidle to two other approaches of leveraging multiple gene region data. We found that Sidle had the least bias in non-phylogenetic alpha diversity, feature-based measures of beta diversity, and the reconstruction of individual clades. With a curated database, Sidle also provided the most precise species-level resolution. Availability and ImplementationSidle is available under a BSD 3 license from https://github.com/jwdebelius/q2-sidle

bioinformatics↗

bioRxiv2019

Sub-species niche specialization in the oral microbiome is associated with nasopharyngeal carcinoma risk in an endemic area of southern China

Oral health and changes in the oral microbiome have been associated with both local and systemic cancer. Poor oral hygiene is a known risk factor for Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma (NPC), a virally-associated head and neck cancer endemic to southern China. We explored the relationship between NPC and the oral microbiome using 16s rRNA sequencing in a study of 499 NPC patients and 495 population-based age and sex frequency-matched controls from an endemic area of Southern China. We found a significant reduction in community richness in cases compared to controls. Differences in the overall microbial community structure between cases and controls could not be explained by other potential confounders; disease status explained 5 times more variation in the Unweighted UniFrac distance than the next most explanatory variable. In feature-based analyses, we identified a pair of co-excluding Granulicatella adiacens (G. adicans) amplicon sequence variants (ASVs) which were strongly associated with NPC status and differed by a single nucleotide. The G. adicans variant an individual carried was also associated with the overall microbial community based on beta diversity. Co-occurrence analysis suggested the two G. adicans ASVs sit at the center of two co-excluding clusters of closely related organisms. Our results suggest there are differences in the oral microbiome between NPC patients and healthy controls and these may be associated with both a loss of microbial diversity and niche specialization among closely related commensals. Importance The relationship between oral health and the risk of Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma has been previously established. However, the role of oral microbiome has not been evaluated in the disease in a large epidemiological study. This paper clearly establishes a difference in the oral microbiome between NPC patients and healthy controls which cannot be explained by other confounding factors. It furthermore identifies a pair of closely related co-excluding organisms associated with the disease, highlighting the importance of modern methods for single nucleotide resolution in 16s rRNA sequence characterization. To the best of our knowledge, this is one of the first examples of cancer-associated niche-specialization of the oral microbiome.

microbiology↗

bioRxiv2018

American Gut: an Open Platform for Citizen-Science Microbiome Research

Although much work has linked the human microbiome to specific phenotypes and lifestyle variables, data from different projects have been challenging to integrate and the extent of microbial and molecular diversity in human stool remains unknown. Using standardized protocols from the Earth Microbiome Project and sample contributions from over 10,000 citizen-scientists, together with an open research network, we compare human microbiome specimens primarily from the USA, UK, and Australia to one another and to environmental samples. Our results show an unexpected range of beta-diversity in human stool microbiomes as compared to environmental samples, demonstrate the utility of procedures for removing the effects of overgrowth during room-temperature shipping for revealing phenotype correlations, uncover new molecules and kinds of molecular communities in the human stool metabolome, and examine emergent associations among the microbiome, metabolome, and the diversity of plants that are consumed (rather than relying on reductive categorical variables such as veganism, which have little or no explanatory power). We also demonstrate the utility of the living data resource and cross-cohort comparison to confirm existing associations between the microbiome and psychiatric illness, and to reveal the extent of microbiome change within one individual during surgery, providing a paradigm for open microbiome research and education.\n\nImportanceWe show that a citizen-science, self-selected cohort shipping samples through the mail at room temperature recaptures many known microbiome results from clinically collected cohorts and reveals new ones. Of particular interest is integrating n=1 study data with the population data, showing that the extent of microbiome change after events such as surgery can exceed differences between distinct environmental biomes, and the effect of diverse plants in the diet which we confirm with untargeted metabolomics on hundreds of samples.

microbiology↗