bioRxiv Science⌕ Search

Biology subjects

Cochard, H.

Publications and source records attributed to Cochard, H..

17 recordsLinked to original sources

Rooting for water: Bridging Plant Hydraulics and Ecohydrology to Predict Drought Stress

Forests regulate climate and sustain biodiversity, but their resilience is increasingly threatened by drought-induced hydraulic failure, when xylem water transport is impaired by embolism. A critical but poorly constrained determinant of this risk largely due to limited observations of deep root water uptake is the amount of root-accessible (sub)soil water storage (SR), which governs land-atmosphere exchanges during prolonged dry periods. While ecohydrological theory has long suggested a balance between soil water storage in the rooting zone, vegetation growth and drought tolerance, this concept has not yet been integrated into predictive models of hydraulic failure. Here we propose a novel, process-based inversion framework that integrates ecohydrological optimality theory with principles of plant hydraulic to infer SR. Using the SurEau plant hydraulic model, we estimate the SR value that balances the costs of soil exploration with the avoidance of drought-induced hydraulic damage. Applied first to a well-instrumented Mediterranean Quercus ilex forest, the inferred SR closely matched independent neutron probe and eddy covariance measurements and accurately reproduced observed drought responses, including leaf water potential and sap flow dynamics. We then scaled the approach across European forests remotely-sensed data, to assess spatially explicit SR estimates and associated hydraulic failure risk. Across more than 20 species and sites, inferred SR and drought stress metrics aligned with field observations and outperformed estimates based on conventional soil databases or remote-sensing-only approaches. By linking plant physiology and ecohydrological theory within a scalable inversion framework, this approach improves predictions of forest drought risk under climate change.

ecology↗

Beyond climatic drought indices : an hydraulic approach to quantifying forest water stress

The article introduces a new Forest Stress Index (ISF) based on a plant hydraulic modelling approach rather than classical climatic drought indices. Unlike other index like scPDSI or SPEI, ISF is grounded in xylem embolism dynamics simulated with the mechanistic SurEau model. The goal is to better link climatic anomalies to tree physiological functioning and mortality risk. ISF is defined using a locally adapted ideotype characterized by an optimal P50 value under a reference hydraulic functioning threshold. Simulations are performed across Europe and France using multiple climate datasets. The index is robust to model parameterization choices and assumptions about plant functional traits. Results show strong spatial and temporal consistency and significant correlations with SPEI and scPDSI. However, ISF more strongly highlights extreme drought years and exhibits a more skewed distribution. Future projections under SSP5-8.5 indicate a widespread increase in hydraulic stress with strong regional contrasts. Overall, ISF provides a mechanistic and complementary drought indicator more directly linked to forest mortality processes.

plant biology↗

Multiscale intraspecific variation and coordination of hydraulic traits in silver fir

O_LIIntraspecific variability in hydraulic and morphological traits may alter projections of forest vulnerability to climate change. Recognizing multiscale nature is essential, as trait relationships within populations may not reflect those across the species range. C_LIO_LIWe assessed variability in 11 traits in 10 natural populations of Abies alba across environmental and phylogeographic gradients to evaluate potential impacts on drought vulnerability. We quantified trait variation within and among populations, tested effects of climate, phylogeny and local factors, and evaluated trait coordination across scales. C_LIO_LIHydraulic safety traits and wood density showed low variability, indicating strong constraints. In contrast, water-use and efficiency traits were highly variable. Aridity influenced several traits, but reduced variance was detected only for leaf residual conductance and succulence consisted with stabilising selection. Trait coordination was weak within populations than among populations. C_LIO_LIOverall, A. alba combines constrained hydraulic safety traits with variable water use traits. This may buffer drought impacts but limits shifts in hydraulic safety margins, potentially increasing risks of hydraulic failure, especially in humid environments where populations lack the capacity to tolerate prolonged dry periods. Thus, our findings highlight the need to account for scale-dependent trait variability, coordination, and their underlying drivers when predicting species adaptive capacity to drought. C_LI

plant biology↗

Phenotypic variability of hydraulic residual conductance and its temperature sensitivity in Abies alba

Residual water losses after stomatal closure have recently been identified as key determinants of drought-induced hydraulic failure, particularly under heatwave conditions. However, little is known about the intraspecific variability of residual conductance (gres) and its thermal sensitivity. Here, we investigated the genetic and environmental sources of variation in gres and its associated thermal parameters (phase transition temperature T_, and temperature sensitivities Q10a and Q10b) in Abies alba Mill., together with vulnerability to xylem embolism (P50). Measurements were performed using the Drought-Box on seven French provenances grown in a common garden to assess genetic variability, and on trees growing across contrasting forest sites to quantify phenotypic plasticity. Seasonal dynamics and within-canopy microclimatic effects were also examined, and linked to needle biochemical traits. Residual conductance exhibited a marked seasonal decline, with high values in newly formed needles followed by a stabilization from late summer to the following spring, closely tracking the accumulation of cuticular waxes. In contrast, Klason lignin content showed little seasonal variation. Difference between provenances was weak for all investigated parameters, suggesting strong constraints on these safety-related traits. By contrast, gres showed significant environmental plasticity, with lower values at more climatically constrained sites, while thermal parameters and P50 remained relatively conserved. Our results identify gres as a developmentally dynamic and environmentally plastic trait in silver fir, potentially representing a key lever of acclimation to drought. Incorporating such variability into mechanistic models should improve predictions of tree vulnerability under future climates combining intensified droughts and heatwaves. Key message.Residual conductance in Abies alba is developmentally dynamic and environmentally plastic but genetically constrained, highlighting its key role in acclimation to drought and heatwave-driven hydraulic failure.

plant biology↗

Root vulnerability to embolism and lack of physiological recovery limit the competitive ability of an invasive palm

O_LIClimate change and invasive species both threaten forest ecosystems. While exacerbated droughts drive tree mortality, species invasion alters forest composition. Invasive plants may be more vulnerable to drought due to acquisitive traits and low embolism resistance, but their potentially superior recovery capacity raises key uncertainties in predicting future species distributions. C_LIO_LIWe compared the drought resistance and recovery of an invasive palm (Trachycarpus fortunei) with two native species (Ilex aquifolium & Tilia cordata) from the Southern Alps. Saplings were exposed to increasing intensities of drought-induced xylem embolism, then rewatered for 45 days. Among others, we tracked net assimilation (Anet), stomatal conductance (gs), and leaf water potential ({Psi}leaf) before and after the drought, and modeled the time to hydraulic failure in leaves, stems, and roots. C_LIO_LIWhile the invasive palm had exceptionally drought-tolerant leaves, its roots were the most drought-sensitive among all species. The palm maintained positive gas exchange until {Psi}leaf of -4 MPa, as some native species; however, it failed to recover from the most severe drought, with simulations showing root embolism preceding leaf failure, unlike native species. C_LIO_LIInvasive plants may match or exceed natives drought resistance, but their inability to recover from extreme droughts could limit their future spread. C_LI

ecology↗

Beyond Proxies: Towards ecophysiological indicators of drought resistance for forest management

As drought-induced mortality increases globally in forest biomes, it becomes necessary for foresters to have access to reliable predictors of species vulnerability to drought and mortality risk under different climatic scenarios. On the one hand, there exist several "operational" indicators of drought resistance, which are based on observations, expert knowledge and species bioclimate (e.g. Ellenberg, Rameau, ClimEssences). On the other hand, as traits can now be measured at high throughput, functional traits (such as plant hydraulic traits) have been increasingly used to assess species vulnerability to hydraulic failure, a key process of tree mortality under drought. However, this mechanistic approach has never been compared to the operational approach. In this study, we review if indicators commonly used by foresters provide information on Abies species vulnerability to hydraulic failure. We measured a set of traits in a common garden experiment of closely related Mediterranean Abies species. These traits were used as inputs to the SurEau model to compute a single indicator of vulnerability (Time to Hydraulic Failure - THF) and to assess mortality risk in future climate. We found that among circum-Mediterranean firs, a high THF was mainly due to high water losses after stomatal closure. Some operational indicators are good proxies of THF, however they are not available for all species, reduce a species to a single value and have the same limitations as species distribution models. We argue that the ecophysiological approach could help foresters in species selection and in estimating the risk faced by forest tree species in a changing climate. While accounting for the variability of traits, hydraulic models can be forced with different climatic scenarios allowing hydraulic failure risk assessment by the end of the century. HighlightsO_LIIntegrating ecophysiological traits in a process-based model allows the computation of an accurate indicator of vulnerability: the Time to Hydraulic Failure (THF). C_LIO_LIFor Abies species, "operational" indicators, i.e. indicators used by foresters and land managers, are mutually consistent and can be simplified proxies of the vulnerability to hydraulic failure. C_LIO_LIMore research on intra-specific variability is needed to assess the evolutionary potential of Euro-Mediterranean Abies species. C_LI

ecology↗

Functional diversity reduces the risk of hydraulic failure in tree mixtures through hydraulic disconnection

Forest ecosystems are increasingly threatened by anthropogenic pressures, especially by the increase in drought frequency and intensity. Tree species mixtures could improve resilience to diverse global anthropogenic pressures. However, there is still little consensus on how tree diversity affects water stress. Although some studies suggest that mixing species with different drought response strategies could be beneficial, the underlying mechanisms have seldom been identified. By combining a greenhouse experiment and a soil-plant-atmosphere hydraulic model, we explored whether mixing a drought avoidant (Pinus halepensis) and a drought tolerant (Quercus ilex) tree species could reduce plant water stress (defined as the risk of hydraulic failure) during extreme drought, compared to their respective monocultures. Our experiment showed that mixing species with divergent drought response strategies had a neutral effect on the drought-avoidant species and a positive effect on the drought-tolerant species. The model simulations further suggested that the beneficial effect of mixture on plant water stress during extreme drought was related to changes in the hydraulic connection of the plant from both the soil and the atmosphere. The ability of the drought-avoidant species to disconnect from the soil and the atmosphere limits its exposure to water stress, whereas the ability of the drought-tolerant species to increase its hydraulic connection to the soil lowers its hydraulic risk. This study brings a new insight on the mechanisms and traits combinations improving drought resistance in diversified forests and plantations, with important implications for forest management under climate change.

ecology↗

Hydraulic adjustments of Scots pine colonizing a harsh environment on volcano slopes

The ability of trees to survive and naturally regenerate in increasing drought conditions will depend on their capacity to vary key hydraulic and morphological traits that increase drought tolerance. Despite many studies investigating variability in these drought-tolerant traits, there has been limited investigation into this variability under recurrent severe drought conditions since the establishment phase. We investigated the long-term hydraulic and leaf trait adjustments of Scots pine trees settled in an abandoned slag quarry by comparing them across three different topographic positions inducing contrasted effects on growth and development. We measured xylem and foliar traits to compare the water status of trees according to tree location and to evaluate the respective risk for xylem hydraulic failure using the soil-plant hydraulic model SurEau. Compared to upslope and downslope trees, slope trees exhibited lower growth, vulnerability to embolism, specific hydraulic conductivity and photosynthetic pigment contents, as well as higher water potential at turgor loss point and midday water potentials. The hydraulic adjustments of trees settled on slag slopes reduced the risk for hydraulic failure and thus prevented an increase in embolism compared to downslope and upslope trees. These results suggest a prioritization of hydraulic safety over growth in Scots pine developed in a harsh environment, resulting in a dwarf phenotype.

plant biology↗

Combined drought resistance strategies and the hydraulic limit in co-existing Mediterranean woody species

O_LIWoody species employ various strategies to cope with drought stress. We investigated similarities and differences in response to chronic drought to understand resistance strategies in co-occurring Mediterranean species. C_LIO_LIWe studied five predominant Mediterranean species; Quercus calliprinos, Pistacia palaestina, Pistacia lentiscus, Rhamnus lycioides, and Phillyrea latifolia over two summers at three sites with different aridities. We measured key hydraulic and osmotic traits related to drought resistance, including resistance to embolism ({Psi}50), carbon isotope signature ({delta}13C), pre-dawn ({Psi}PD) and mid-day ({Psi}MD) water potentials, and native ({Psi}s) and full turgor ([Pcy]0) osmotic potentials. C_LIO_LISignificant differences among species appeared in resistance to embolism. The species also showed differences in the water potential plastic response over the dry season. This interspecific variation increased at the end of the dry season and resulted in very narrow hydraulic safety margins (HSM). Consequently, predicted loss of hydraulic conductivity revealed species with significant native embolism. Two of the species also had seasonal changes in osmotic adjustment. C_LIO_LIOur detailed analysis indicates that co-existing Mediterranean woody species combine various drought resistance strategies to minimize mortality risk. However, all of them risk mortality as they approach their hydraulic limit near the dry margin of their distribution. C_LI

plant biology↗

Physiological trait networks enhance understanding of crop growth and water use in contrasting environments

Plant function arises from a complex network of structural and physiological traits. Explicit representation of these traits, as well as their connections with other biophysical processes, is required to advance our understanding of plant-soil-climate interactions. We used the Terrestrial Regional Ecosystem Exchange Simulator (TREES) to evaluate physiological trait networks in maize. Net primary productivity (NPP) and grain yield were simulated across five contrasting climate scenarios. Simulations achieving high NPP and grain yield in high precipitation environments featured trait networks conferring high water use strategies: deep roots, high stomatal conductance at low water potential ("risky" stomatal regulation), high xylem hydraulic conductivity, and high maximal leaf area index. In contrast, high NPP and grain yield was achieved in dry environments with low late-season precipitation via water conserving trait networks: deep roots, high embolism resistance, and low stomatal conductance at low leaf water potential ("conservative" stomatal regulation). We suggest that our approach, which allows for the simultaneous evaluation of physiological traits and their interactions (i.e., networks), has potential to improve crop growth predictions in different environments. In contrast, evaluating single traits in isolation of other coordinated traits does not appear to be an effective strategy for predicting plant performance. Summary statementOur process-based model uncovered two beneficial but contrasting trait networks for maize which can be understood by their integrated effect on water use/conservation. Modification of multiple, physiologically aligned, traits were required to bring about meaningful improvements in NPP and yield.

plant biology↗

Seasonal and long-term consequences of esca on grapevine stem xylem integrity

Hydraulic failure has been extensively studied during drought-induced plant dieback, but its role in plant-pathogen interactions is under debate. During esca, a grapevine (Vitis vinifera) disease, symptomatic leaves are prone to irreversible hydraulic dysfunctions but little is known about the hydraulic integrity of perennial organs over the short- and long-term. We investigated the effects of esca on stem hydraulic integrity in naturally infected plants within a single season and across season(s). We coupled direct (ks) and indirect (kth) hydraulic conductivity measurements, and tylose and vascular pathogen detection with in vivo X-ray microtomography visualizations. We found xylem occlusions (tyloses), and subsequent loss of stem ks, in all of the shoots with severe symptoms (apoplexy) and in more than 60% of the shoots with moderate symptoms (tiger-stripe), and no tyloses in shoots that were currently asymptomatic. In vivo stem observations demonstrated that tyloses were observed only when leaf symptoms appeared, and resulted in more than 50% PLC in 40% of symptomatic stems, unrelated to symptom age. The impact of esca on xylem integrity was only seasonal and no long-term impact of disease history was recorded. Our study demonstrated how and to what extent a vascular disease such as esca, affecting xylem integrity, could amplify plant mortality by hydraulic failure. HighlightOur study reveals that esca can critically affect xylem water movement in grapevine perennial organs, by the presence of plant-derived tyloses.

plant biology↗

Modelling live fuel moisture content at leaf and canopy scale under extreme drought using SurEau-Ecos, a lumped plant hydraulic model

O_LIWater content in living vegetation (or live fuel moisture content, LFMC), is increasingly recognized as a key factor linked to vegetation mortality and wildfire ignition and spread. Most often, empirical indices are used as surrogates for direct LFMC measurements. C_LIO_LIIn this paper, we explore the functional and ecophysiological drivers of LFMC during drought at the leaf and canopy scale using the SurEau-Ecos model, and a three years dataset of leaf and canopy scale measurements on a mature Quercus ilex forest, including an extreme drought. The model is based on forest hydrology and plant hydraulics and allows to simulate temporal variations of water potential and content at a daily time step. At leaf level, it simulates the relationship between water potential and water content by separating the apoplasm and the symplasm. Symplasm water content is modeled using the pressure volume curve theory, and apoplasm water content is modelled using the xylem vulnerability to cavitation. Fuel moisture content was upscaled to the canopy level by accounting for foliage mortality estimated from drought induced cavitation. C_LIO_LIThe model was parameterized either with site-measured traits or using a calibration procedure, and compared with water potential and LFMC measured at leaf level, and NDVI variation measured at canopy level and taken as a surrogate for foliage mortality. C_LIO_LIAt leaf level, LFMC prediction using measured hydraulic traits could be improved by considering year-to-year osmotic adjustments. At canopy level, foliage mortality due to drought induced cavitation was a key driver of LFMC decline during the most extreme drought. C_LIO_LIA sensitivity analysis showed that parameters driving soil water balance (leaf area index, soil water capacity, and regulation of transpiration) and parameters determining pressure volume curves are key traits driving LFMC dynamics at leaf level. At the canopy level, parameters that drives hydraulic failure were the most sensitive and included, both soil water balance parameters and hydraulic traits (the leaf vulnerability to cavitation) were the main drivers of LFMC decline during extreme drought. C_LIO_LIWe also showed that under normal historic weather conditions, most variation of LFMC are linked to reversible symplasm dehydration, however under future, hotter and dryer conditions, most variations are due to the decline canopy of LFMC driven by foliage mortality. C_LI

ecology↗

Delayed effect of drought on the xylem vulnerability to cavitation in Fagus sylvatica L.

Knowledge on variations of drought resistance traits is needed to predict the potential of trees to adapt to severe drought events expected to be more intense and frequent. Xylem vulnerability to cavitation is among the most important traits related to drought-induced mortality and exhibits a large variability between species. Acclimation of this trait to environmental conditions implies changes in the xylem structure and organization, leading previous studies to investigate its variations under conditions preserving growth. In European beech saplings, we assessed the effect of droughts of on the vulnerability to cavitation in branches that develop during recovery. The newly formed branches displayed lower vulnerability to cavitation in the plants that underwent the severest droughts leading to native embolism; the pressure that induces 50% loss of conductance being of -3.98 MPa in severely droughted plants whereas it was of -3.1 MPa in control plants, respectively. Although unexpected, these results argue for an acclimation, and not a weakening, of this trait to drought events. Key messagesevere water stress make the future developed shoots less vulnerable to xylem cavitation.

plant biology↗

SurEau.c : a mechanistic model of plant water relations under extreme drought

We describe the operating principle of the detailed version of the soil-plant-atmosphere model SurEau that allows, among other things, to predict the risk of hydraulic failure under extreme drought. It is based on the formalization of key physiological processes of plant response to water stress. The hydraulic functioning of the plant is at the core of this model, which focuses on both water flows and water pools using variable hydraulic conductances. The model considers the elementary flow of water from the soil to the atmosphere through different plant organs (roots, trunk branches, leaves and buds) that are described by their symplasm and their apoplasm compartments. Within each organ the flow of water between the apoplasm and the symplasm is also represented; as well as the flow outside the system, from the symplasm of each organ to the atmosphere, through the cuticular conductance. For each organ, the symplasm is described by a pressure volume curves and the apoplasm by the vulnerability curve to cavitation of the xylem. The model can thus compute the loss of conductance caused by cavitation, a leading mechanisms of plant desiccation and drought-induced mortality. Some example simulations are shown to illustrate how the model works.

plant biology↗

Hypomethylated poplars show higher tolerance to water deficit and highlight a dual role for DNA methylation in shoot meristem: regulation of stress response and genome integrity

As fixed and long living organisms subjected to repeated environmental stresses, trees have developed mechanisms such as phenotypic plasticity that help them to cope with fluctuating environmental conditions. Here, we tested the role DNA methylation as a hub of integration, linking plasticity and physiological response to water deficit in the shoot apical meristem of the model tree poplar (Populus). Using a reverse genetic approach, we compared hypomethylated RNAi-ddm1 lines to wild-type trees for drought tolerance. An integrative analysis was realized with phytohormone balance, methylomes, transcriptomes and mobilomes. Hypomethylated lines were more tolerant when subjected to moderate water deficit and were intrinsically more tolerant to drought-induced cavitation. The alteration of the DDM1 machinery induced variation in DNA methylation in a cytosine context dependent manner, both in genes and transposable elements. Hypomethylated lines subjected to water deficit showed altered expression of genes involved in phytohormone pathways, such as salicylic acid and modified hormonal balance. Several transposable elements showed stress- and/or line-specific patterns of reactivation, and we could detect copy number variations for two of them in stressed ddm1 lines. Overall, our data highlight two major roles for DNA methylation in the shoot apical meristem: control of stress response and plasticity through transduction of hormone signaling and maintenance of genome integrity through the control of transposable elements.

plant biology↗

A new mechanism for tree mortality due to drought and heatwaves

AO_SCPLOWBSTRACTC_SCPLOWPlants tend to die earlier in hot and drought conditions, but the underlying mechanisms are not yet understood. I propose here a new mechanism by which excessive residual water losses caused by high cuticular permeabilities and a high leaf-to-air vapor pressure deficits would trigger uncontrolled and sudden cavitation events. The combination of heat and drought stresses may therefore lead to an unsuspected risk of hydraulic failure. I explored this hypothesis with a new mechanistic model. The simulations support this hypothesis and highlight the critical role played by the cuticle phase transition temperature. Experiments are now awaited to confirm these predictions.

plant biology↗

Plants resistance to drought relies on early stomata closure

Plant resistance to drought has long been thought to be associated with the ability to maintain transpiration and photosynthesis longer during drought, through the opening of stomata. This premise is at the root of most current framework used to assess drought impacts on land plants in vegetation models. We examined this premise by coupling a meta-analysis of functional traits of stomatal response to drought (i.e. the water potential causing stomatal closure,{Psi} close) and embolism resistance (the water potential at the onset of embolism formation,{Psi} 12), with simulations from a soil-plant hydraulic model. We found that{Psi} close and{Psi} 12 were equal (isometric) only for a restricted number of species, but as {Psi}12 decreases, the departure from isometry increases, with stomatal closure occurring far before embolism occurs. For the most drought resistant species ({Psi}12<-4.2 MPa),{Psi} close was remarkably independent of embolism resistance and remained above -4.5 MPa, suggesting the existence of a restrictive boundary by which stomata closure must occur. This pattern was supported by model simulations. Indeed, coordinated decrease in both{Psi} close and{Psi} 12 leads to unsuspected accelerated death under drought for embolism resistant species, in contradiction with observations from drought mortality experiments. Overall our results highlight that most species have similarity in stomatal behavior, and are highly conservative in terms of their water use during drought. The modelling framework presented here provides a baseline to simulate the temporal dynamic leading to mortality under drought by accounting for multiple, measurable traits.

plant biology↗