Comprehensive evaluation of differential serodiagnosis between Zika and dengue viral infection
Diagnostic testing for Zika virus (ZIKV) or dengue virus (DENV) infection can be accomplished by a nucleic acid detection method; however, a negative result does not exclude infection due to the low virus titer during infection depending on the timing of sample collection. Therefore, a ZIKV- or DENV-specific serological assay is essential for the accurate diagnosis of patients and to prevent potential severe health outcomes. A retrospective study design with dual approaches of collecting human serum samples for testing was developed. All serum samples were extensively evaluated by using both non-infectious virus-like particles (VLPs) and soluble non-structural protein 1 (NS1) in the standard immunoglobulin M (IgM) antibody-capture enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (MAC-ELISA). Both VLP- and NS1-MAC-ELISAs were found to have similar sensitivity for detecting anti-premembrane/envelope and NS1 antibodies from ZIKV-infected patient sera. Group cross reactive (GR)-antibody-ablated homologous fusion peptide-mutated (FP)-VLPs consistently showed higher P/N values than homologous wild-type VLPs. Therefore, FP-VLPs were used to develop the algorithm for differentiating ZIKV from DENV infection. Overall, the sensitivity and specificity of the FP-VLP-MAC-ELISA and the NS1-MAC-ELISA were each higher than 80% with no statistical significance. A novel approach to differentiate ZIKV from DENV infection serologically has been developed. The accuracy can reach up to 95% when combining both VLP and NS1 assays. In comparison to current guidelines using neutralization tests to measure ZIKV antibody, this approach can facilitate laboratory screening for ZIKV infection, especially in regions where DENV infection is endemic and capacity for neutralization testing does not exist.