Biology subjects

Butlin, R.

Publications and source records attributed to Butlin, R..

5 recordsLinked to original sources

bioRxiv2026

Benchmarking Geometric Morphometric Methods: A Performance Evaluation for Gastropod Shell Shape Analyses

Understanding morphological variation is crucial for the study of speciation and for conservation as it helps in assessing biodiversity and predicting responses to environmental changes. These approaches are broadly applicable but are especially valuable in marine environments, where species are often elusive, difficult to study, and face heightened threats from rapid environmental shifts. The marine snail Littorina saxatilis is notable for its extensive polymorphism in shell shape, size, and colour, with ecotypes that evolve in response to environmental forces including wave exposure and crab predation. Morphometric tools have been central to investigating the mechanisms driving this phenotypic divergence; yet, a direct comparison of their methodological efficacy is lacking. Here, we took advantage of L. saxatilis ecotypes to contrast three morphometric approaches: elliptical Fourier analysis (EFA), landmarks-based geometric morphometrics (GM), and the growth-based model implemented in the ShellShaper software (SS). We assessed their clustering power, biological interpretability, robustness to measurement error and transferability among datasets. Our findings provide insights to guide method selection in studies aimed at exploring morphological variation: EFA is better suited for high-throughput screening and describing intermediate shapes; SS offers superior clustering power with highly interpretable growth parameters; and GM is best for detailed anatomical studies but is less efficient for large datasets. We provide guidelines to align method selection with specific research goals, balancing analytical efficiency with the required morphological and biological insight. By following this framework, researchers can ensure that robust morphological analysis is achieved, which is essential not only for elucidating mechanisms of adaptation and speciation but also for effective management and conservation of marine biodiversity.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2026

Inversions support both parallel and location-specific adaptations in snail ecotypes

Replicated hybrid zones between ecotypes established over within shore environmental gradients provide an opportunity to study the genomic architecture of barriers to gene flow. The marine snail Littorina fabalis segregates locally into dwarf and large ecotypes over wave-exposure gradients on northwestern European shores. Previous work focusing on a hybrid zone in Sweden revealed strong genetic differentiation between the ecotypes, concentrated in 12 putative chromosomal inversions. Here we compare the Swedish hybrid zone with samples from France distributed across a similar wave-exposed gradient. Our aims were to test if similar exposure gradients promote parallel ecotype distributions and hybrid zones, and if similar genomic architectures contribute to divergence and adaptation across the gradients. Unpredictably, we found that the shell size cline was reversed in France compared to Sweden, with small individuals occupying the more-sheltered end of the environmental gradient in Sweden but the more-exposed end in France. We also observed a cline in shell colour in France, whereas nearly all Swedish snails were yellow. Using whole-genome sequencing, we found similar levels of genetic differentiation between ecotypes in both places. Most of the differences were accounted for by the same 15 inversions, and the arrangement clines showed similar associations to the wave-exposure gradient in both hybrid zones. These inversions were enriched in SNPs differentiating the ecotypes that were either specific to one hybrid zone or showed reversed cline patterns between zones. Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) detected significant associations between genomic regions within inversions and shell size in Sweden, while one inversion was associated with colour in France. Our results show that the same inversions play a dual role: they support ecotype differences across similar environmental gradients in distant locations, while also contribute site-specific variation contributing to local adaptation.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2023

Coupling of 12 chromosomal inversions maintains a strong barrier to gene flow between ecotypes

Chromosomal rearrangements lead to the coupling of reproductive barriers, but whether and how they contribute to completion of speciation remains unclear. Marine snails of the genus Littorina repeatedly form hybrid zones between taxa segregating for inversion arrangements, providing opportunities to study this question. Here, we analysed two adjacent transects across hybrid zones between large and dwarf ecotypes of Littorina fabalis covering wave exposure gradients in a Swedish island. Applying whole-genome sequences we found 12 putative inversions reaching near differential fixation between the opposite ends of each transect, and being in strong linkage disequilibrium. These inversions cover 20% of the genome and carry 93% of divergent SNPs. Bimodal hybrid zones in both transects indicate that the two ecotypes of Littorina fabalis maintain their genetic and phenotypic integrity following contact due to strong coupling between inversion clines that strengthened the reproductive barrier. The bimodality resulting from the linked inversions extends into collinear parts of the genome, suggesting a genome-wide coupling. Demographic inference suggests that the coupling built up during a period of allopatry, and has been maintained for more than 1K generations after secondary contact. Overall, this study shows that the coupling of multiple chromosomal inversions contributes to strong reproductive isolation. Importantly, two of the inversions overlap with inverted genomic regions associated with ecotype differences in a closely-related species (L. saxatilis), suggesting the same regions, with similar structural variants, repeatedly contribute to ecotype evolution in distinct species.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2023

Understanding the adaptive role of chromosomal inversions across large geographical scales: The potential of pool-seq data

A growing body of research shows that chromosomal inversions, where each arrangement is associated with a certain environment and maintains a set of adaptive alleles, make an important contribution to local adaptation. However, inversions often remain unexplored across large geographical scales. It is unclear whether inversions contribute to adaptation across species ranges, which environmental factors affect arrangement frequencies, and whether the adaptive content of the same arrangement varies between locations. Here, we discuss ideas of how allele frequency data (e.g. pool-sequencing data) can be used to learn about inversions in a simple and cost-effective way. If populations connected by migration differ in arrangement frequency, plotting their SNP allele frequencies against each other will reveal a parallelogram whose corners reflect arrangement frequencies. We demonstrate the usefulness of this approach in locally-adapted populations of the intertidal snail Littorina saxatilis (Olivi). For twelve inversions, we estimate arrangement frequencies in 20 populations across the European species range. While roughly half of the inversions contribute to adaptation to the well-studied contrast between wave-exposed and crab-infested habitats, the other half likely contribute to adaptation to shore height. We also find evidence for geographical variation in arrangement content, suggesting variation in adaptive role.

evolutionary biology↗

bioRxiv2018

Genomic architecture of parallel ecological divergence: beyond a single environmental contrast

The genetic basis of parallel ecological divergence provides important clues to the operation of natural selection and the predictability of evolution. Many examples exist where binary environmental contrasts seem to drive parallel divergence. However, this simplified view can conceal important components of parallel divergence because environmental variation is often more complex. Here, we disentangle the genetic basis of parallel divergence across two axes of environmental differentiation (crab-predation vs. wave-action and low-shore vs. high-shore habitat contrasts) in the marine snail Littorina saxatilis, a well established natural system of parallel ecological divergence. We used whole-genome resequencing across multiple instances of these two environmental axes, at local and regional scales from Spain to Sweden. Overall, sharing of genetic differentiation is generally low but it is highly heterogeneous across the genome and increases at smaller spatial scales. We identified genomic regions, both overlapping and non-overlapping with recently described candidate chromosomal inversions, that are differentially involved in adaptation to each of the environmental axis. Thus, the evolution of parallel divergence in L. saxatilis is largely determined by the joint action of geography, history, genomic architecture and congruence between environmental axes. We argue that the maintenance of standing variation, perhaps as balanced polymorphism, and/or the re-distribution of adaptive variants via gene flow can facilitate parallel divergence in multiple directions as an adaptive response to heterogeneous environments.

evolutionary biology↗