bioRxiv Science⌕ Search

Biology subjects

Azriel, D.

Publications and source records attributed to Azriel, D..

3 recordsLinked to original sources

Conditional and marginal SNP-heritability to leverage ancestral and environmental diversity

SNP-heritability is defined as the fraction of variance of a trait that is explained by the SNPs in a genome-wide association study. Several methodologies have been proposed to estimate this quantity. More recent methods aim to do so with ancestrally diverse datasets and yet obtain a single heritability for an entire dataset, which we refer to as marginal heritability. However, the different underlying subpopulations that compose a genetically diverse dataset might have different environmental and genetic exposures, and thus may have different heritabilities. In order to address this, we propose a conditional SNP-heritability approach that allows to estimate multiple SNP-heritabilities on a dataset corresponding to different ancestral compositions and environmental exposures. We take a careful statistical approach, including estimation of conditional genetic and environmental variances, and calculation of standard errors via a combination of the delta method with bootstrapping. We validate our method via extensive simulations. We then apply it to an ancestrally and socio-economically diverse dataset of 6603 subjects aged around 9 to 11 from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development study, and illustrate how the SNP-heritability of intelligence scores can change due to differing extrinsic variances in different socio-economic groups, which coincides with previous work in the literature. This conditional estimation approach can be a valuable tool for understanding differences in risks across subpopulations. Our work here improves on existing methodology and allows us to leverage the heterogeneity of the data to obtain new insights.

genetics↗

When can whole-genome SNP heritability be reliably estimated from summary statistics?

LD Score Regression (LDSC) is a prominent method, which estimates whole-genome SNP heritability from summary statistics via the slope of a linear regression of GWAS test statistics corresponding to a trait of interest against LD scores. It was claimed by the LDSC authors that the free intercept in the regression accounts for confounding bias such as population stratification. In this study, we argue that the intercept in LDSC must be fixed to 1 for accurate SNP heritability estimation. We show both theoretically and with simulations that the estimated intercept does not accurately capture population stratification effects, and that it adversely affects the accuracy of the heritability estimate introducing bias and increasing variance. Fixing the intercept to 1 eliminates bias and reduces variance when no population stratification is present. On the other hand, under population stratification, LDSC is biased with both the free and the fixed intercept. Additionally, we show that estimated standard errors in LDSC are underestimated, potentially leading to false-positives in downstream GWAS analyses.

genetics↗

Partitioning Fraction of Variance Explained into Strong Localized Effects and Weak Diffuse Effects

High-dimensional genetic data present substantial challenges for estimating the fraction of variance explained (FVE) by genome-wide single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). In the context of genetics the VFE is called SNP heritability. Standard approaches for FVE estimation, such as GWAS heritability (GWASH) and linkage disequilibrium score (LDSC) regression, typically assume Gaussian distributions for SNP effect sizes. However, empirical evidence indicates that SNP effects are often heavy-tailed, with a small subset of variants exerting disproportionately large influence. Such settings violate the recently established bounded-kurtosis effect (BKE) condition, under which these FVE estimators are consistent. Consequently, widely used methods may yield severely biased estimates when strong effects are present. We introduce a decomposed FVE estimation framework that accommodates heavy-tailed and heterogeneous SNP effect distributions. The proposed approach partitions total heritability into contributions from strong and weak genetic effects, estimating the former using low-dimensional adjusted R2 and the latter using an extension of FVE estimation methodology that remains valid under BKE compliance. We further develop a test for detecting violations of the BKE condition and compare several high-dimensional screening procedures for identifying strong-effect SNPs when they are not known in advance. Simulation studies show that the proposed decomposition substantially improves estimation accuracy over existing approaches in the presence of heavy-tailed effects. Application to the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) Study demonstrates the practical utility of the method, yielding more reliable heritability estimates for the PolyVoxel Score, a neuroimaging-based biomarker linked to iron accumulation. Our results highlight the importance of accommodating effect heterogeneity in large-scale genomic studies.

genetics↗